Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Climate Progress

Climate Progress



Energy and Global Warming News for September 29: Boxer, Kerry set to introduce climate bill in Senate; China leads way for solar energy: "If the U.S. doesn't get serious, China's going to own this industry."

Posted: 29 Sep 2009 09:37 AM PDT

Boxer, Kerry Set to Introduce Climate Bill in Senate

Ending some nine months of closed-door deliberations, Sens. Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.) and John Kerry (D-Mass.) will release global warming legislation Wednesday that they hope will be the vehicle for broader Senate negotiations and an eventual conference with the House.

The bill's authors said last week that they expect to start hearings early next month on the bill, with a markup in Boxer's Environment and Public Works Committee to follow soon thereafter. They also acknowledged that their legislation is just a "starting point" in a bid to win over moderate and conservative Democrats, as well as Republicans.

"I hope what we've done is constructive and well-received," Kerry, the chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, said Thursday. "I have no pretensions, and neither does Barbara, that this will be the final product. It is a starting point, a commitment, full-fledged, across party lines to do what we need to do to protect the planet for the next century."

The Boxer-Kerry bill will build in large part off H.R. 2454 (pdf), legislation approved in June by the House following several marathon months of negotiations that involved lawmakers representing coastal and industry-heavy districts. Exactly what is the same in the two bills remains to be seen. As for differences, Senate Democratic aides say they expect the legislation to divert from the House bill's 17 percent emissions target for 2020 and go with an even more aggressive 20 percent limit. The bill also will stay silent on exactly how the Senate should divide up emission allowances.

At least five other Senate committees are also expected to contribute to the climate debate. The Foreign Relations and Agriculture committees are preparing language without convening a markup.

Commerce Chairman Jay Rockefeller (D-W.Va.) said he will hold votes on his pieces of the global warming bill. And the same goes for Finance Chairman Max Baucus (D-Mont.), who last week told reporters that provisions on international trade and the allocation of emission allowances would be marked up provided Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) says the bill is "clearly moving."

Sen. Jeff Bingaman (D-N.M.) has already approved legislation (S. 1462 (pdf)) out of the Energy and Natural Resources Committee that includes a nationwide renewable electricity standard and a raft of other energy incentives, including a provision that could bring oil and gas rigs closer to Florida's Gulf Coast. Bingaman is also planning a hearing Thursday on several competing cost estimates associated with the House-passed climate bill. The session, which was postponed once earlier this month, now gives senators an early public forum to sound off on the Boxer-Kerry bill.

Already last week, several Democratic senators working outside of the Boxer-Kerry camp said their ideas would be melded into the legislation at a later date. "It's going to need a lot of work," said Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio).

Brown said he did not expect the Boxer-Kerry bill to include language adopted in the House that tries to assist energy-intensive manufacturing industries, including steel, pulp and paper and cement.

"My understanding is they did not include the House language on manufacturing," Brown added. "But I've been talking to them about it. They are very open to it. They are in no way dismissive."

Sen. Debbie Stabenow (D-Mich.) said she also does not think her concerns will be addressed in the initial draft from Boxer and Kerry. That means further efforts on issues related to agriculture, offsets and energy intensive industries.

"We will have to take a look at the language and then determine it from there," Stabenow said.

China leads way for solar energy

Next month, Santa Clara's Applied Materials Inc. is scheduled to open a giant solar energy R&D center. The company is investing up to $300 million in the facility. It will not be situated in California, nor in the United States, but in Xian, China. Because China's where the action is.

"If the U.S. doesn't get serious, China's going to own this industry," said Applied Materials spokesman David Miller. He points to the Manhattan Project-like push for alternative energy adopted by Chinese officials, which includes up to $60 billion annually in government investment. And here? "Here, we're way behind," said Miller. "We're still messing around with energy bills. We need to get serious, to get capital spending flowing, to get the government truly behind it, to get focused."

Miller and his company are not simply blowing smoke. In as little as two years, analysts predict, China will be the world's biggest consumer of solar energy. By 2013, its clean tech market could amount to $1 trillion annually, according to a report earlier this month from the China Greentech Initiative, a consortium of U.S. and Chinese companies that includes Cisco Systems and the Silicon Valley VC firm VantagePoint Venture Partners, which specializes in clean tech investments.

Neither is Applied Materials alone in its views. I've heard them similarly expressed by numerous Bay Area executives and investors with business ties to China. "They get that these are the industries of the 21st century," says VantagePoint managing partner Alan Salzman, whose Bay Area clean tech investments include Tesla Motors, BrightSource Energy and Solazyme. "The level of support for green tech there is breathtaking. It exceeds anything done here on a state or federal level."

As if any more wake-up calls were needed, two other VantagePoint Venture Partners' portfolio companies, Santa Clara's Miasolé, which produces advanced, thin-film solar panels, and Sunnyvale's Bridgelux, developer of energy-efficient LED lighting, are reluctantly considering locating their manufacturing facilities outside the United States.

"From a global competitiveness perspective, we're just not there," said Salzman.

East Africa Drought In Fifth Year, Millions Hungry

Drought for a fifth year running is driving more than 23 million east Africans in seven countries towards severe hunger and destitution, international aid agency Oxfam said on Tuesday.

Launching a $9.5 million (6 million pounds) appeal, it said the situation was being worsened by high food prices and conflict. The most badly hit nations are Kenya, Ethiopia, Somalia and Uganda.

Malnutrition is now above emergency levels in some areas and hundreds of thousands of valuable cattle are dying.

"This is the worst humanitarian crisis Oxfam has seen in east Africa for over ten years," Paul Smith Lomas, Oxfam's East Africa Director, said in a statement.

He said failed and unpredictable rains were ever more common in the region, and that broader climate change meant wet seasons were becoming shorter. Droughts have increased from once a decade to every two or three years.

"In Wajir, northern Kenya, almost 200 dead animals were recently found around one dried-up water source," Lomas said..

"People are surviving on two litres of water a day in some places — less water than a toilet flush.. The conditions have never been so harsh or so inhospitable, and people desperately need our help to survive."

Some 3.8 million Kenyans, a tenth of the population, need emergency aid, Oxfam said, partly because food prices have risen to 180 percent above average.

One in six children are acutely malnourished in Somalia, the charity said, while conflict meant people were less able to grow food and drought is ravaging areas where people have fled. Half the population — more than 3.8 million people — are affected.

In Ethiopia, 13.7 million people are at risk of severe hunger and need help, Oxfam said. Many are selling cattle to buy food. Farmers in northern Uganda have lost half their crops.

EU, U.S. eye green goods tax pact in climate fight

EU diplomats told Reuters that under a plan being discussed by Brussels and Washington, the 30 nations in the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development and China would agree a global pact to phase out import tariffs on goods such as wind turbines, renewables and green technologies.

But any deal is unlikely to include environmentally friendly hybrid cars, the diplomats said.

"The talks are entering an advanced stage. Brussels and Washington hope this could be one of the incentives needed to get China on board in the lead up to the Copenhagen climate change talks," one EU diplomat told Reuters.

A spokeswoman for the U.S. Trade Representative's office said the United States and the EU had been pushing within the Doha round of world trade talks since November 2007 for a deal to cut tariffs on environmental goods "and continue to work closely in pushing for concrete progress."

"We remain eager to move ahead with negotiations to eliminate tariff barriers on climate-friendly technologies and spur momentum on a larger WTO Doha package on environmental goods and services," said USTR spokeswoman Carol Guthrie.

U.S. businesses such as United Technologies Corp and General Electric Co, that are frustrated with the slow pace of the Doha round, have urged the Obama administration to consider alternative paths to reach a deal to boost trade in environmental goods and services.

"It's a chance to jump-start U.S. trade policy and aid global climate negotiations at the same time," said Jake Colvin, vice president for global trade policy at the National Foreign Trade Council, a U.S. business group.

China is on course to become the world's largest producer of wind turbines in the world this year and is a major manufacturer of solar products.

Britain to host pre-Copenhagen climate talks

Britain said on Monday it would host a meeting of major economies next month ahead of talks to reach a new U.N deal to fight climate change.

The United States had asked Britain to hold the meeting of the 17-member Major Economies Forum (MEF) it set up earlier this year to provide an informal forum to discuss climate issues in London on October 18 and 19.

The discussions come less than two months before about 190 nations gather for talks in Copenhagen in December to forge a successor to the emissions-capping pact known as the Kyoto Protocol.

"MEF will cover most of the climate issues discussed in the official UNFCCC (UN Framework Convention on Climate Change) talks ahead of Copenhagen but is not an official part of the negotiations," Britain's Department of Energy and Climate Change said in a statement.

"However, it will provide valuable contribution towards Copenhagen if developed and developing countries can reach a shared understanding and build consensus on some general principles.

"Real commitment from all countries is needed to secure a breakthrough deal."

Delegates are currently meeting in Thailand for two weeks of talks to try to settle on the outline of a tougher pact to replace the Kyoto Protocol.

A spokeswoman for the department said the MEF was likely to meet again following the London talks and a further meeting on the eve of the Copenhagen talks was also likely.

Going green at Whitey's, with aid from government

Whitey's Auto Mall is going green, and the business secured $20,000 in federal funds to help.

Sen. Sherrod Brown, D-Ohio, announced Saturday that Ohio will receive more than $10 million in federal funds to support renewable energy and energy efficiency projects. The funding was made available through the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Rural Energy for America Program.

Whitey's plans to install a geothermal climate control system for its new Mercedes showroom, which opened this month. Co-owner Dirk Schluter said drilling started three months ago for the energy-efficient heating and cooling system.

"We're looking for whatever we can to go green. If this system works well, we plan on doing more," he said..

The business applied for the grant a few months ago, and only learned of the award Saturday.

Brown, a leading advocate in Congress for creation of a clean energy industry, is the first Ohioan to serve on the Senate Agriculture Committee in more than 40 years.

"These funds will help Ohio's small towns and rural communities make strides in energy efficiency and energy innovation," he said in a news release. "Across the state, these are projects that work to reduce our dependence on foreign energy and are key to our future economic development and prosperity."

Schluter said Whitey's is interested in wind turbines and new lamps for the entire dealership, which will mean considerable savings in utilities.

He said the Park Avenue West dealership's new auto body shop uses a waterborne paint system, which contains and emits less organic solvent, is less flammable and has a lower toxicity.

"It's a pretty big green investment we made," he said.

U.N. warns deadline imminent on climate change agreement

The United Nations on Monday warned world leaders they have only 70 days to reach a new deal to limit global warming.

"Time is not just pressing. It has almost run out," U.N. climate chief Yvo de Boer said of leaders' dwindling time before they meet in Copenhagen to finalize a pact.

"As many leaders have said, there is no Plan B," he said. "If we don't realize Plan A, the future will hold us to account for it."

But only hours after negotiations began, rich and poor nations were already flinging their usual rebukes at one another for failing to do their part to reach a deal to replace the Kyoto Protocol, which expires in 2012.

Talks have been deadlocked for months over the industrial nations' refusal to commit to sufficiently deep cuts or provide billions of dollars to poor nations to help them adapt to the effects of climate change and transition to a low-carbon economy.

Major developing nations, such as India and China, have refused to agree to binding targets altogether and are leery of demands that their commitments be monitored and verified as part of any agreement.

Indian delegates called Monday for emissions cuts by developing nations of 40 percent to 45 percent below 1990 levels. And Sudan, speaking for the Group of 77 developing nations and China, said industrialized nations must provide financial help.

But the U.S. shot back that developing countries would have to do their part – short of binding targets – to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and for the first time agree to a system that would monitor and verify their promised actions.

The need for a deal was driven home by a U.N. report last week that showed climate-related events such as the melting of glaciers and polar ice sheets and the increasing acidification of the oceans are happening much faster than scientists had predicted even two years ago.

CIA opens center for climate change

The Central Intelligence Agency announced plans to launch a center on climate change to examine the potential security risks of environmental issues.

The CIA said it was working on its new Center on Climate Change and National Security to examine the national security impact of environmental issues such as population shifts, rising sea levels and increased competition for natural resources.

CIA Director Leon Panetta described the center as an effective support tool for U.S. lawmakers examining international agreements on the environment.

"Decision makers need information and analysis on the effects climate change can have on security," said the director. "The CIA is well positioned to deliver that intelligence."

The CIA will use the center to coordinate with other members of the intelligence community to review and declassify imagery and other data for use in environmental and climate-related issues.

Google Earth 3D climate change simulator unveiled — starring Al Gore

Posted: 29 Sep 2009 09:19 AM PDT

Google is using its Google Earth mapping tool to simulate on a 3D map of the world the predicted effects of climate change until the year 2100.

Using data provided by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the search giant created new layers for Google Earth showing the range of expected temperature and precipitation changes under different global emissions scenarios that could occur throughout the century.

The Sydney Morning Herald further reports these "new tools were introduced in partnership with the Danish Government ahead of the United Nations Climate Change Convention in December."  And as as HuffingtonPost reports, "Al Gore stars" in the Google Earth climate simulator video:

From Cope to Hope: Twitter to the rescue?

Posted: 29 Sep 2009 07:55 AM PDT

http://www.bizzia.com/behindthebuzz/files/2009/06/cope-hope-flagpole-english-low-res.jpgCan Twitter save civilization? We're about to find out.

As the clock winds down on the big climate negotiation in Copenhagen this December (formally known as the 15th Conference of the Parties, or COP-15), the future of the planet and its inhabitants may be in the hands of tweeters, especially tots, teens and twenty-somethings.

Several groups are attempting to mobilize a worldwide mandate for action in Copenhagen, calling for boots to hit streets and thumbs to hit keyboards, to harness the power of Twitter, FaceBook, MySpace, You Tube, FlickR, text messaging and the potential power of the PDA Nation.

One of my favorites (in part because I've been a sometime advisor on it) is a campaign called Hopenhagen, launched last week during "climate week" in New York City. At the request of the United Nations, the International Advertising Association is applying its creative powers to a viral effort in which young people will petition for a "definitive, equitable and effective" climate agreement at COP-15.

Led by the global communications powerhouse Ogilvy & Mather, the campaign urges young people to become citizens of a Hopenhagen community, complete with a virtual passport. With help from corporate giants Coca Cola, Siemens and SAP, and with support from a growing list of "Friends of Hopenhagen" who range from Reader's Digest and the Wall Street Journal to Mother Jones magazine, Ogilvy will deploy media and billboards in major cities to promote the power of the grassroots.

Rather than complaining about an infringement on its name, the City of Copenhagen has agreed enthusiastically to rename itself "Hopenhagen" in December, replacing Cs with Hs where the city's name appears at the airport and on highway signs leading to COP-15.

Hopenhagen is one of several current opportunities for youth to help shape the future they will inherit, and for old-timers like me to improve the future we will pass along. Here are some of the others:

Tck Tck Tck: Organized by the Global Campaign for Climate Action, Tck Tck Tck is an alliance of civil society organizations, trade unions, faith groups and individuals using social media and the internet to demand a "fair, ambitious and binding" climate treaty.. Partners include the World Wildlife Fund, Oxfam and Amnesty International, the Union of Concerned Scientists, the World Council of Churches and the Global Campaign Against Poverty, among others.

International Day of Climate Action – Oct. 24, 2009: 350.org is a coalition of more than 200 organizations encouraging local people to hold thousands of events around the world on Oct. 24 to "show our world and its decision-makers just how big, beautiful and unified the climate movement really is". The group's web site offers a tool kit to help local activists organize their events.

So far, 1,578 events are scheduled in 125 countries. The goal is to push for a global agreement that reduces atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases to a maximum of 350 parts per million – the ambitious emissions reduction target advocated by Dr. James Hansen, the outspoken chief climate scientist at NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies.

1Sky: Back in the United States, the meta-group 1Sky is mobilizing people to shower Senators with telephone calls in call for action on a climate bill this year. 1Sky has set up a system that makes it easy to let your fingers to do the marching straight into the offices of your Senators.

Raise Your Voice: The Danish government, YouTube and Google have created a web site for people to post their own videos and "raise their voices" about global climate change. The best of the videos will be featured Dec. 15 during a CNN/YouTube "debate" at Copenhagen and on an Earth Globe at the conference.

Focus the Nation: FTN has created a network to help climate activists communicate about their plans and to join groups working on climate campaigns this fall. FTN also helps local groups organize Clean Energy Forums.

Apollo Alliance: The Apollo Alliance is working with Ceres, the Clean Economy Network and others to help businesses lobby the Senate Oct. 6-7 for clean energy and climate legislation. (To point out that businesses have a stake in climate action is a vast understatement. Converting the world to clean energy technologies is likely to be the biggest market opportunity in the history of commerce.) For more information, go to www.wecanlead.org.

Power Shift 2009: A project of the Energy Action Coalition, Power Shift has organized tens of thousands of young people to march in Washington, D.C. in the past. This fall, it is organizing regional summits – 11 so far — to "exercise the political power of young voters and ask President Obama and Congress to pass a clean energy jobs plan by December to rebuild our economy, end our dependence on dirty energy, and bring America lasting security."

To veterans of the Vietnam era like me, social networking seems less impressive than taking to the streets. For my generation, social commitment meant braving enlistment in a war, or a concussion and jail time to protest the war. Some old-fashioned protest still is underway today in acts of civil disobedience, lately against coal mining and coal power plants. Ask Jim Hansen, who is one of several people facing jail time for a protest against mountain top removal in Appalachia.

When I asked a friend of mine – a young mother with pre-teen children – why more of today's youth aren't marching in the old way, she replied: "Kids today don't march. They network." Clearly, we need both.

To us wonks and wags emerged in climate policy, a campaign like Hopenhagen may seem light on substance. I think we'll be surprised. Boiling global warming's esoterica into a simple but true choice between "hope" and "cope" might be the key to engaging the masses.

  • So, if you want to make a difference by forcing leaders to lead, here's what you can do:
  • Sign up for one of the mobilizations above. Better yet, sign up for all of them;
  • In a response to this post, alert us to other mobilization opportunities;
  • Help these efforts go viral by alerting your social networks;
  • Follow emerging developments as we approach COP-15, including more opportunities to raise your voice. One source of information is the COP-15 web site.

With opponents of action fighting to maintain a status quo that cannot be sustained, it apparently will take a planetary village to deal with climate change.

– Bill Becker

UK Met Office: Catastrophic climate change, 13-18°F over most of U.S. and 27°F in the Arctic, could happen in 50 years, but "we do have time to stop it if we cut greenhouse gas emissions soon."

Posted: 28 Sep 2009 07:41 PM PDT

Finally, some of the top climate modelers in the world have done a "plausible worst case scenario," as Dr Richard Betts, Head of Climate Impacts at the Met Office Hadley Centre, put it today in a terrific and terrifying talk (audio here, PPT here).

No, I'm not taking about a simple analysis of what happens if the nation and the world just keep on our current emissions path.  We've known that end-of-century catastrophe for a while (see "M.I.T. doubles its 2095 warming projection to 10°F — with 866 ppm and Arctic warming of 20°F").  I'm talking about running a high emissions scenario (i.e. business as usual) in one of the few global climate models capable of analyzing strong carbon cycle feedbacks.  This is what you get [temperature in degrees Celsius, multiple by 1.8 for Fahrenheit]:

Graphic of chnage in temperature

The key point is that while this warming occurs between 1961-1990 and 2090-2099 for the high-end scenarios without carbon cycle feedbacks, in about 10% of Hadley's model runs with the feedbacks, it occurs around 2060.  Betts calls that the "plausible worst case scenario.."  It is something the IPCC and the rest of the scientific community should have laid out a long time ago.

As the Met Office notes here, "In some areas warming could be significantly higher (10 degrees [C = 15F] or more)":

  • The Arctic could warm by up to 15.2 °C [27.4 °F] for a high-emissions scenario, enhanced by melting of snow and ice causing more of the Sun's radiation to be absorbed.
  • For Africa, the western and southern regions are expected to experience both large warming (up to 10 °C [18 °F]) and drying.
  • Some land areas could warm by seven degrees [12.6 F] or more.
  • Rainfall could decrease by 20% or more in some areas, although there is a spread in the magnitude of drying. All computer models indicate reductions in rainfall over western and southern Africa, Central America, the Mediterranean and parts of coastal Australia.
  • In other areas, such as India, rainfall could increase by 20% or more. Higher rainfall increases the risk of river flooding.

Large parts of the inland United States would warm by 15°F to 18°F, even worse than the NOAA-led 13-agency impacts report found "Our hellish future: Definitive NOAA-led report on U.S. climate impacts warns of scorching 9 to 11°F warming over most of inland U.S. by 2090 with Kansas above 90°F some 120 days a year — and that isn't the worst case, it's business as usual!"

Dr Betts added: "Together these impacts will have very large consequences for food security, water availability and health. However, it is possible to avoid these dangerous levels of temperature rise by cutting greenhouse gas emissions. If global emissions peak within the next decade and then decrease rapidly it may be possible to avoid at least half of the four degrees of warming."

A DECC spokesman said: "This report illustrates why it is imperative for the world to reach an ambitious climate deal at Copenhagen which keeps the global temperature increase to below two degrees."

Betts "presented the new findings at a special conference" today.  "4 degrees and beyond at Oxford University, attended by 130 international scientists and policy specialists, is the first to consider the global consequences of climate change beyond 2 °C."  You can find all the talks here.

The UK Telegraph story is here.  The Guardian story is "Met Office warns of catastrophic global warming in our lifetimes:  Study says 4C rise in temperature could happen by 2060, Increase could threaten water supply of half world population":

When they ran the models for the most extreme IPCC scenario, they found that a 4C rise could come by 2060 or 2070, depending on the feedbacks. Betts said: "It's important to stress it's not a doomsday scenario, we do have time to stop it happening if we cut greenhouse gas emissions soon." Soaring emissions must peak and start to fall sharply within the next decade to head off a 2C rise, he said. To avoid the 4C scenario, that peak must come by the 2030s.

Again, this is not the likely impact for 2060 if we fail to act aggressively, but it is a plausible worst-case scenario that should invalidate all economic cost-benefit analysis done to date (see "Harvard economist disses most climate cost-benefit analyses").

Kudos to Betts and the Met Office for this important, uncharacteristically blunt, and long-overdue analysis.

Nation's largest utility pulls the plug on the Chamber over climate denial. Exelon CEO Rowe says, "Putting a price on carbon is essential, because it will force us to do the cheapest things, like energy efficiency, first."

Posted: 28 Sep 2009 05:24 PM PDT

"The carbon-based free lunch is over. But while we can't fix our climate problems for free, the price signal sent through a cap-and-trade system will drive low-carbon investments in the most inexpensive and efficient way possible," said Rowe. "Putting a price on carbon is essential, because it will force us to do the cheapest things, like energy efficiency, first."

"Inaction on climate is not an option," said Rowe. "If Congress does not act, the EPA will, and the result will be more arbitrary, more expensive, and more uncertain for investors and the industry than a reasonable, market-based legislative solution."

John RoweExelon issued a press release today announcing CEO John Rowe's decision to leave the U.S. Chamber of Commerce.  It includes the above excerpts from his speech calling for immediate action by Congress.

More and more utilities have cut the power to the Chamber (see "Will last company to leave the Chamber's Boardroom please turn off the lights!") — though they have been in the dark a long time (see "Chamber admits calling for 'Scopes monkey trial of the 21st century' was dumb — but it still apes the deniers").

Okay, enough puns.  Here's the background, from Wonk Room:

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce is the largest lobbying force in the nation, promoting a right-wing agenda as the "voice of business." The Chamber claims that a cap-and-trade program to limit global warming pollution would "strangle the economy" and has even called for a "Scopes monkey trial" on the science of global warming.Today, Exelon CEO John Rowe announced that his company — the largest electric utility company in the United States — would not renew its membership in the U.S. Chamber of Commerce because of its opposition to global warming action. In his keynote address to the annual conference of the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE), the nation's largest association of energy efficiency experts, Rowe said that the Chamber's multi-million-dollar campaign against clean energy legislation is incompatible with Exelon's commitment to climate change leadership. As Rowe said when he accepted a leadership award from the Chicagoland Chamber of Commerce in 2008:

Exelon has staked out an industry-leading position on the issue of climate change and, in the spirit of Daniel Burnham, we have launched our own "not so little plan" to eliminate the equivalent of our entire carbon footprint by the year 2020. I do not know if it will stir men's souls, but I hope it will stir policymakers and others in our industry to action.

Confirming Exelon's decision to ThinkProgress, a spokesperson explained that "Exelon is a big supporter of climate legislation." Exelon is the third energy company to sever ties with the U.S. Chamber of Commerce in the past week, joining Pacific Gas & Electric and PNM Resources.

Energy and Global Warming News for September 28: G20 leaders agree to phase-out fossil fuel subsides; China sees emissions trading in next economic plan

Posted: 28 Sep 2009 03:21 PM PDT

G20 Leaders Agree to Phase Out Fossil Fuel Subsidies

World leaders gathered in Pittsburgh for the Group of 20 summit agreed Friday afternoon to phase out fossil fuel subsidies over time, approving language that does not outline a specific timetable for the phase-out and makes clear that poorer citizens may still receive help in paying their energy bills.

But the wording of the statement, championed by the Obama administration, signals the world's most influential nations are taking an initial, tentative step away from the fossil fuels that power their economies.

"We commit to rationalize and phase out over the medium term inefficient fossil fuel subsidies that encourage wasteful consumption," the statement said. "As we do that, we recognize the importance of providing those in need with essential energy services, including through the use of targeted cash transfers and other appropriate mechanisms. This reform will not apply to our support for clean energy, renewables and technologies that dramatically reduce greenhouse gas emissions."

The United States and many other countries around the world provide financial aid — in the form of both direct payments and tax breaks — to help produce oil, natural gas and other fuels that produce carbon dioxide, which has contributed to rapid climate change over the past half century. According to the Environmental Law Institute, the U.S. government provided $72 billion in subsidies to the fossil fuel industry between 2002 and 2008.

China Sees Emissions Trading in Next Economic Plan

China plans to include a pilot emissions trading system in its five-year plan for economic development until 2015, the Environment Ministry said on Sunday, but declined to comment on whether it would cover carbon dioxide.

The government is already experimenting with small-scale schemes to tackle acid-rain causing sulphur dioxide and other pollutants using market mechanisms.

It has been coy about the potential for expanding these, or adding greenhouse gases to the list of pollutants that can be controlled and traded, but is apparently keen to at least continue exploring their potential.

A trial system for trading in permits to pollute was listed as one of four main emissions reductions goals in official comments about a blueprint for growth in China from 2011 to 2015, which bureaucrats are still thrashing out.

China is now the world's top annual emitter, and President Hu Jintao pledged at the United Nations to take on a "carbon intensity" goal that would oblige it to cut the amount of carbon dioxide produced for each dollar of its economic output.

Many carbon traders hope this could pave the way for a market like the one currently used in Europe, and have been rushing to secure a potentially lucrative foothold in China even though it is unclear how easy it will be to make money there.

Religious Groups Push For Climate Change Legislation

When Orthodox Jews met with top White House adviser David Axelrod and a handful of U.S. senators this month as part of an annual lobbying effort, they talked up climate change legislation as a way to improve security for the United States and Israel. "America's reliance on imported oil from the Arab Middle East has been a grave concern for a very long time," says Nathan Diament, public policy director for the Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America. "The Jewish community is interested in energy independence."

But the Jewish delegation also based its case for a climate change bill, which cleared the House earlier this year, on another premise: the Bible. "We are getting ready to read Genesis and the creation story in our synagogues in a few weeks," Diament says. "Our responsibility to tend the garden is part of our understanding of the Torah and of our worship." Indeed, some Jews have begun referring to their green activism as "creation care," a term coined by environmentally inclined evangelical Christians.

As environmental interests begin pressing the Senate to pass major climate legislation before next year's midterm elections, groups and activists from across the spectrum of American religious traditions have emerged as an integral part of the effort. Some denominations and faith-based organizations are planning grass-roots campaigns around the bill for this fall. The White House's faith-based advisory council has convened a climate change task force. And Pope Benedict XVI's environmental proclamations, including writing recently that "the environment is God's gift to everyone," have earned him the nickname the "green pope."

At a time when many senators are skittish about adopting the House climate bill's cap-and-trade provision because of fears it could further slow the economy, religious activists may prove crucial to building support, or at least dampening opposition, among important religious constituencies. Religious conservatives, for instance, generally oppose more government regulation. And many African-Americans, among the most religious demographic groups in the country, worry about cap-and-trade's impact on manufacturing jobs. Faith-based environmentalists have responded to such doubts with a moral case that climate change will disproportionally affect the world's poor by causing food shortages, drought, and coastal flooding. "The faith community talks about climate legislation differently than scientists or environmentalists," says Cassandra Carmichael, director of the Washington office of the National Council of Churches. "We frame it in terms of the people impacted, which can bring in legislators who hadn't thought in those terms."

n the House, religious activists helped to narrowly pass a climate bill in June. A group called the American Values Network, founded by the religious outreach director for Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign, Burns Strider, bought Christian radio ads promoting the bill in conservative congressional districts. The progressive group Faith in Public Life funded polling that showed most evangelicals and Catholics support efforts to combat climate change. Religious lobbyists, meanwhile, won a provision in the House bill guaranteeing that houses of worship are eligible for federal subsidies for retrofitting energy-inefficient buildings.

The stepped-up environmental efforts of religious groups in Washington have paralleled a grass-roots effort among religious Americans to green their congregations. An ecumenical group called GreenFaith recently launched a program to certify green houses of worship. Earlier this month, the Environmental Protection Agency unveiled a tool kit to help churches, synagogues, and mosques earn its Energy Star ratings for their facilities. The Obama administration is reportedly considering the idea of a faith-based office at the EPA to expand its work with religious communities.


Senate climate-change bill calls for 20% cut in greenhouse ... Los Angeles Times


The Definition of a Tax New York Times


Germany eyes nuclear revival United Press International

Germany eyes nuclear revival
United Press International

Met Office warns of catastrophic global warming in our lifetimes guardian.co.uk


Barack Obama is cooling on global warming Telegraph.co.uk


EU Alone and Lonely on Carbon New York Times


Is 350 the New 450 When It Comes to Capping Carbon Emissions? New York Times


Fossil fuel subsidies and climate change Public Radio International PRI

Fossil fuel subsidies and climate change
Public Radio International PRI

Climate Progress

Climate Progress



WashPost recycles another denier WSJ op-ed, this time from coal apologist Bjorn Lomborg. Funny how two new senior Post editors came from the WSJ.

Posted: 28 Sep 2009 10:12 AM PDT

Questions of the Day:  Is this just a desperate attempt by The Washington Post to drive traffic to its website, by publishing outrageous crap designed to stir controversy?  Is it just a coincidence that Marcus Brauchli, the Post's new executive editor (as of September 2008), had been the WSJ's editor, and that Raju Narisetti, who was named a managing editor at the Post in January, had been a deputy managing editor at the WSJ?  You can ask the Post Ombudsman, Andy Alexander, for his answer by e-mail at ombudsman@washpost.com or by phone at 202-334-7582.

Garbage

Fred Hiatt keeps delivering self-inflicted body blows to the dwindling reputation of the Washington Post editorial page — see Editorial page editor Hiatt just recycled a right-wing WSJ op-ed by Reagan's chief economist Martin Feldstein. It's dĂ©jĂ  vu all over again today, but now with a Lomborg op-ed as the piece of recycled garbage.

Just last month, the right-wing Wall Street Journal editorial page ran a disinformation-filled piece from Lomborg (debunked here, "The Bjorn Irrelevancy: Duke dean disses Danish delayer").  It had  lines like:

… agreements to reduce carbon emissions are costly, politically arduous and ultimately ineffective….

But his research demonstrates the futility of trying to use carbon cuts to keep temperature increases under 2 degrees Celsius (3.6 degrees Fahrenheit)….

Hiatt, who  is as zealously anti-environmental as he is pro-recycling, apparently feels that Lomborg's lies aren't getting a fair enough hearing in the media, so he runs a piece titled, "Costly Carbon Cuts" with lines like:

… many politicians are vowing to make carbon cuts designed to keep expected temperature rises under 3.6 degrees (2.0 Celsius). Yet it is nearly impossible for these promises to be fulfilled.

Now you're probably saying to yourself, wait a minute, Joe, Hiatt's version of Lomborg's piece is completely different than the WSJ's because he forced Lomborg to put temperature in Fahrenheit with Celsius in parentheses like a real American editor, not the reverse, like those world-government, Europhile types at the WSJ ed board.  But I digress.

Lomborg has done the denier two-step with Hiatt — going straight from denying the problem to saying it's hopeless to even try to solve.  And I'm sure future generations, if no one else, will note that if we don't keep total warming below 3.6 F or 2 C, it will be because of people like Lomborg and Hiatt who are devoting all of their efforts to convincing opinionmakers that it can't and shouldn't be done!!

I'm not going to waste time debunking Lomborg yet again [see "Lomborg skewers the facts, again" and "Debunking Lomborg — Part III and "Voodoo Economists 4: The idiocy of crowds or, rather, the idiocy of (crowded) debates"].  But I'm happy to feature the work of guest debunkers (see "Lomborg's main argument has collapsed)."  And you can read a good critique by Grist's Miles Grant of what the Post and Lomborg have done here.

But I will acknowledge there is something in this piece that I haven't seen before — Lomborg's (non)apology for coal:

Today, coal accounts for almost half of the planet's electricity supply, including half the power consumed in the United States. It keeps hospitals and core infrastructure running, provides warmth and light in winter, and makes lifesaving air conditioning available in summer. In China and India, where coal accounts for more than 80 percent of power generation, it has helped to lift hundreds of millions of people out of poverty.

There is no doubt that coal is causing environmental damage that we need to stop. But a clumsy, radical halt to our coal use — which is what promises of drastic carbon cuts actually require — would mean depriving billions of people of a path to prosperity.

No need to have any discussion whatsoever of climate impacts, say that pesky 6,700-page report by world leaders concludes that climate change means "billions of people will be condemned to poverty and much of civilisation will collapse."

And certainly Hiatt would never require Lomborg to explain that the international deal they are trying so hard to kill doesn't require "drastic carbon cuts" for the developing world and certainly doesn't require a "radical halt" to their coal use — or that both China and India have announced their intention to restrict the growth of carbon emissions and aggressively pursue clean energy.

This isn't about the truth — and it's not about exercising editorial judgment that Lomborg deserves some of the most precious space in the media world, the op-ed page of the Washington Post.  No, it's strictly about generating attention — for the faux environmentalist Lomborg and the faux editor Hiatt.

Or perhaps the reason the Post is recycling the WSJ's garbage is that it's now being run by the folks who used to run the Journal.

What do you think?

Clinton Climate Initiative on "creative destruction": From buggy whips to the global warming imperative

Posted: 28 Sep 2009 08:34 AM PDT

This is a Wonk Room repost.

On the final day of the Clinton Global Initiative, the Wonk Room caught up with Ira Magaziner, the senior advisor for policy development in the Clinton White House and now the chairman of the William J. Clinton Foundation's Climate Initiative. We discussed the Clinton Climate Initiative's approach to the challenge of global warming, including its work to advance energy efficiency projects in the world's cities from the Empire State Building to Lagos, Nigeria. Magaziner also directly addressed why critics argue that advocacy of clean energy is a socialistic economy killer, citing Adam Smith's recognition of the need for governmental action to address market externalities. As we neared the conclusion of the interview, Magaziner tied all the threads of the conversation together into one impressive discourse on building a clean-energy economy:

CREATIVE DESTRUCTION — PAST VS. THE FUTURE

MAGAZINER: Schumpeter — yet another capitalist economist — talked about creative destruction. Periodically, as new technologies develop and new needs arise, business systems and economic systems need to be remade — creatively destroyed and remade. We don't need a buggy whip industry any more. We've got automobiles. And the buggy whip guys may not like it, but they ought to switch to making automobiles if they're going to have a future.

What always happens in those periods of transformation is that some people oppose and some people see the future. We went from mainframe computers to minicomputers to PCs. And as we went through those transformations, different companies succeeded. DEC and Wang and companies that were the minicomputer companies didn't understand the potential of the PC. So you had the Dells and others who developed them. In some cases, companies do make the transformation and they go with the future instead of the past.

We have a similar situation with clean energy and energy efficiency. You have some companies now, like GE, and there's a bunch of others, who are saying, "I want to go with the future, and I'm going to invest in wind, I'm going to invest in solar. I'm going to invest in these things that I know are going to eventually be the future." And you've got others who say, "I'm going to defend the past and stick with what I've got," and fight Congress to prevent the future from coming.

BRINGING THE FUTURE FASTER

MAGAZINER: I think, in this case, in the case of clean energy, we have a public interest in bringing the future faster, because of global warming. We know that if we don't bring the future faster with clean energy and with energy efficiency, that it's going to have a tremendous economic and social cost. Therefore, we have to accelerate the process of that future coming.

That's why government has to especially play a role in this revolution. I mean, it played a stimulative role in the Internet revolution, but in this revolution it has to play a much more active role. Because the negative consequences of not doing so are going to cause governments and people and economies tremendous unhappiness.

There have been so many reports written. The thousands of scientists in the International Panel on Climate Change established that the world is warming, they've established what the impacts can be, and there's only now a few dissident scientists left. The overwhelming 99.9 percent opinion is very clear on this.

Economists like Nicholas Stern who have done serious work on this have said we can lose 5 to 10 percent of GDP in the next ten years, fifteen years if we don't act, because of all the major dislocations. And if we spend one percent of our GDP to bring the transformation faster, we'll save ten percent or 15 percent of our GDP. So there are enough studies out there.

THE CLINTON CLIMATE INITIATIVE

MAGAZINER: What we're trying to do with the Clinton Climate Initiative is to make it real.

It's very important that global leaders, the political leaders agree to set targets to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. It's very important they pass legislation to put a price on carbon — because it does have a price for society — to help speed the transformation.

What we've said, what we're doing, is say, even after that's done, what you're going to still need projects that demonstrate in large scale how to do this, what the business models are what the government models should be, so that government money gets spent well, carbon credit money gets spent well, and ultimately businesses can move into this in an accelerated way to make this happen. And so that's why we've focused on these projects.

We've worked on energy efficiency, clean energy, and the third area we're working on is forests, preserving forests around the world. What we as a human race have been doing is at the same time we're putting all this CO2 into the air — which is poisoning the atmosphere — we're cutting down the forests — which are nature's way of taking carbon dioxide out of the air. We're making the problem worse on both ends.

So we have major projects that we're doing in Indonesia, and Cambodia, Guyana — Africa and the tropical countries — to help preserve forests and create economic value in preserving forests.

So that's what we're up to and we're trying to make our contribution. That's going to require a lot of different groups working in a lot of different ways to make a contribution.

THE MULTIPLIER EFFECT

MAGAZINER: What we do is: we do these projects and can measure the direct impact, and say there's this many millions of tons less of CO2 going into the air because of the projects we have done. And then we're creating these models which we can spread to others, so that we can have a multiplier effect that multiplies the impact of what the direct projects we're doing can accomplish.

That's why when we show that we can do an integrated waste management project in Delhi — in a very complicated, large city that's never had integrated waste management — what we did in Delhi is the first integrated waste management project in the whole of southern Asia. We showed that it can work, it's actually returning a profit to the commercial developers, it's saving the city money, and it's working in terms of making Delhi a cleaner place.

And now there are ten other cities that are ready to do it. As soon as we finish the project in Lagos — Lagos, Nigeria is a place with 21 million people in that city, growing a million and a half people per year — and they had no waste system. We're putting the first integrated waste system there. We're now doing it in Dar Es Salaam and Tanzania. We have requests from a number of other African cities. So our goal is to create these models and then spread them, because that's really where we're going to get at the problem.

Markey spokesman: "The Breakthrough Institute seems to believe, much as the Bush administration did, that technology will solve all, even without a market."

Posted: 28 Sep 2009 07:52 AM PDT

"Your manuscript is both good and original. But the part that is good is not original, and the part that is original is not good."

Those words, "attributed" to the 18th century English essayist Samuel Johnson, are a perfect summation of the oeuvre of The Breakthrough Institute (TBI).  So it is with their latest attack on the climate and clean energy bill — "Climate Bill Analysis Part 20 [!!!]: Over-Allocation of Pollution Permits Would Result in No Emissions Reduction Requirement during Early Years of Climate Program."

And no, I can't bring myself to link to their crap — that is apparently what the status quo media is for (see "Memo to media: Don't be suckered by bad analyses from TBI and "The Audacity of Nope: George Will embraces the anti-environment message of TBI" and "TBI is lying about Obama, misstating what CBO concluded about Waxman-Markey, and publishing deeply flawed analyses" and "Will America lose the clean-energy race? Only if we listen to the disinformers of TBI").

Indeed, this time I don't even need to debunk their "analysis" — which looks strangely like the evil twin of a blog post I wrote two weeks ago that they never even reference (see "EIA stunner: By year's end, we'll be 8.5% below 2005 levels of CO2 — halfway to climate bill's 2020 target").

No, someone in the media has actually done a bang-up job of it already, truly a fine piece of journalism by Greenwire, "Institute's critique of Waxman-Markey draws fire" (subs. req'd), which I  excerpt at length below:

U.S. businesses won't need to cut carbon dioxide emissions until possibly as late as 2018 under the cap-and-trade program that would be created by the House-passed climate bill, according to a new analysis that examined the recession's effects on emissions.

The Breakthrough Institute, which favors direct investment in clean energy sources, examined the House bill's policies in light of the federal Energy Information Administration's September report forecasting a 6 percent drop in carbon dioxide emissions in 2009, which followed a 3 percent decline in 2008. Declines were spurred by the recession and lower natural gas prices that caused power generators to switch away from coal, EIA said.

Those downturns equal almost half of the 17 percent reduction in carbon emissions that the bill seeks by 2020. Reductions in greenhouse gases mandated by the measure are pegged to emissions in 2005, which had levels higher than they are now.

The legislation would require businesses to buy allowances for their carbon emissions, but it would give away the bulk of those allowances in the program's early years. That, combined with the economic downturn, would create low allowance prices, giving businesses the option to sidestep penalties for several years, the Breakthrough Institute report says….

The institute issued the report to give the Senate important data as it crafts climate legislation, Jenkins said. But there were immediate questions about the study's credibility and the motivations behind it. An EIA expert said he was skeptical of the findings.

"The numbers sound awfully large for me," said J. Alan Beamon, EIA's director of the coal and electric power division, who worked on an April analysis examining the effects of the House bill. "If [emissions] are down a year or two because of a recession, they're not going to make that big of a difference over the long haul." Beamon said he had not looked at the Breakthrough Institute's analysis and said he did not immediately have time to study it.

The report is the 20th from the Breakthrough Institute examining the bill from Reps. Henry Waxman (D-Calif.) and Ed Markey (D-Mass.) Some Democrats and environmentalists distrust the Oakland, Calif.-based institute because of its contrarian positions.

Breakthrough was founded by Michael Shellenberger and Ted Nordhaus, who in 2004 wrote "The Death of Environmentalism," an essay arguing that traditional environmentalism lacked solutions to address climate change. The institute does not back the cap-and-trade approach to driving down carbon emissions.

"The Breakthrough Institute keeps coming out with these pointless reports attacking Waxman-Markey," said Joe Romm, senior fellow at the Center for American Progress, a think tank headed by John Podesta, who was chief of staff to former President Clinton. "Waxman-Markey is kinda old news. The Senate is constructing a bill now."

"I'm confident that the smart senators and people who write this bill will fix it," Romm said.

Changes to legislation already are under way. Sen. Barbara Boxer, who chairs the Environment and Public Works Committee, which is writing a climate bill, will raise the House's 17 percent reduction in carbon emissions to 20 percent by 2020, Senate Democratic aides have said. The California Democrat will argue that it is not a sizable increase, given the EIA projection of a 6 percent drop in emissions this year….

The House bill creates a cap-and-trade program that would start in 2012 and reduce allowable emissions levels each year, hitting a 17 percent reduction below 2005 levels in 2020 and 83 percent by 2050. Because it is set to pre-recession emissions, when the cap starts, "U.S. emissions may still be recovering to pre-recession levels and may remain substantially lower than historic 2005 levels," the Breakthrough report says….

EIA in its analysis of Waxman-Markey, which was done in April, assumed a 3 percent downturn in emissions in 2009 and a 2 percent downturn in 2008, a total 3 percent short on the decline EIA now projects.

"It's hard to believe that 3 percent would really change the overall 40 years of the program," EIA's Beamon said. In addition, he said, businesses plan for the long term.

For his part, Romm said he does not trust the institute's analysis.

"They just keep publishing analysis after analysis, half of which are wrong, the other half of which aren't terribly original," Romm said. "They have many biased studies that do not stand the light of day."

The institute, he said, is "trying to scare people into opposing the bill."

"One assumes the people who write the final bill will use the new [emissions] numbers, and then the problem goes away," Romm said….

Jenkins did the analysis for the institute. He does not have a background in economics.

"It's not an economic analysis," Jenkins said. "It's based on the economic forecasts of the EIA and CBO. Beyond that, it's relatively simple arithmetic that any old competent policy analyst such as myself is capable of."

A new analysis?

Romm, an acting assistant secretary for energy efficiency and renewable energy in the Clinton administration's Energy Department, questioned whether the Breakthrough report uncovers anything new. Romm in his Sept. 15 "Climate Progress" blog wrote about EIA carbon emissions numbers under the headline, "EIA stunner: By year's end, we'll be 8.5% below 2005 levels of CO2 — halfway to climate bill's 2020 target."

In the blog post, Romm calls for tightening the emissions reduction target and reducing the number of free permits given to businesses in the early years.

"Everything claims to be a new analysis," Romm said. "It's a new analysis that they glommed from me."

Although Romm did post the blog item, Jenkins said, the Breakthrough Institute's analysis looked beyond the drop in emissions and at the implications of that EIA forecast….

The institute has a "philosophical difference" with the Democratic leadership in that it does not believe that penalizing carbon emission would create a market for clean energy technology, said Eben Burnham-Snyder, spokesman for Markey and the House Select Committee on Energy Independence and Global Warming.

"The Breakthrough Institute seems to believe, much as the Bush administration did, that technology will solve all, even without a market," Burnham-Snyder said. "Waxman-Markey is predicated on the belief that we must invest in technology, but that more clean energy technologies will be invented and deployed by establishing a mandatory market for carbon."

The bill has $200 billion dedicated to clean energy development, Burnham-Snyder said, as well as mandatory carbon emissions cuts.

"By and large, we have tried to engage with those who are willing to have a constructive policy argument," Burnham-Snyder said. "We chose not to engage with those who are not trying to be constructive, with those who are merely trying to stir the pot."

Precisely.

If Obama is going to Copenhagen to push Chicago's Olympic bid this week, he has to go in December to push a climate deal, yes?

Posted: 28 Sep 2009 06:27 AM PDT

http://z.hubpages.com/u/923807_f520.jpg

President Barack Obama, who initially planned to let First Lady Michelle Obama represent the United States in Copenhagen this week, when the International Olympic Committee chooses a site for the 2016 summer games, plans to travel there too….

"There is no greater expression of the support our bid enjoys, from the highest levels of government and throughout our country, than to have President Obama join us in Copenhagen for the pinnacle moment in our bid," said Chicago 2016 Chairman and CEO Patrick G. Ryan.

This is the best news I've heard in a while.

https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjJSS48xrZHcBADT6wD4Q0R7tRvTGR29E358MaPjHKqeg3tfbNrPOL5-383xHhlZC1HRmZbojN8R3Ddrh_03FGDLuq7-3jvVNUtqq7AL9eRrU0E0FHIJb8Nt-I2v3zGxfTGInErUJV4wEgu/s320/new-chicago-olympics-logo.jpg

After all, if the president is going to Copenhagen for something that is relatively inconsequential both substantively and politically — it's not like Illinois is in great jeopardy for the Dems — then I can now predict with high confidence he will be go to Copenhagen in December for the climate talks, which w

ill be crucial for helping achieve a global deal.

Success in Copenhagen this week gets Obama the Chicago Olympics in the final year of his presidency, a tiny, but fleeting, salute (if he gets a second term).  Success in December — not a final deal, of course, but moving the ball forward to achieve such a deal next year — ensures that Obama is not seen as a failed president historically and that he is not viewed as a failure internationally for however long he is president.

Inhofe on why global warming isn't real: "God's still up there."

Posted: 27 Sep 2009 06:08 PM PDT

CALLER: Yes, I agree with the Senator on what he says about the climate change. I believe that the world is just changing like it usually does….

INHOFE: I think he's right. I think what he's saying is God's still up there. We're going through these cycles. … I really believe that a lot of people are in denial who want to hang their hat on the fact, that they believe is a fact, that man-made gases, anthropogenic gases, are causing global warming. The science really isn't there.

Thank God the Senator from Oklahoma is here to promise us that that the Almighty will override at a planetary level the laws of physics He created and simply stop human-emissions of heat-trapping gases from ravaging his Creation.  Now if we can only get Inhofe to tell God to stop all cancers and traffic accidents, too.

More seriously,  the only thing more stunning than the fact that a U.S. Senator — the ranking minority member on the Environment and Public Works committee, no less — would advance such a predeterministic view is that anyone in the media would treat him seriously (see for instance, "NYT's Green Inc. blog wins worst headline of the day").

But this fundamentalist, anti-scientific tripe, far from disqualifying Inhofe, puts him in very good company with other leading conservative politicians:

It bears repeating that the fact the climate has changed in the past, does not mean humans can't change the climate today.  Quite the reverse.  As the famous climatologist Wallace Broecker, climate scientist, wrote in a 1995 Nature article:

The paleoclimate record shouts out to us that, far from being self-stabilizing, the Earth's climate system is an ornery beast which overreacts even to small nudges.

The point is that "natural cycles" do not mean "random cycles."  The climate changes when it is forced to change.  Past warmings were driven by natural forcings, including massive releases of greenhouse gases.  But now humans are dwarfing the natural cycles and natural forcings by pumping out greenhouse gases at a much higher rate than ever occurred in the past — see Humans boosting CO2 14,000 times faster than nature, overwhelming slow negative feedbacks..

If the "Earth's climate system is an ornery beast which overreacts to even small nudges," what will happen to people foolish enough to keep punching it in the face?  The answer is biblical, but rather than divine intervention, it will, I fear, be Hell and High Water.

H/t to Think Progress, which posted the video and gives its background.

On C-Span's Washington Journal this week, Sen. James Inhofe (R-OK), the godfather of global warming deniers, said that he will travel to the climate change summit in Copenhagen this fall to present "another view." "I think somebody has to be there — a one-man truth squad," he said. Throughout the program, Inhofe went through his tattered global warming denier claims: that climate change is a "hoax," that CO2 is not a pollutant, and — latching on to the latest false right-wing talking point — that clean energy legislation will cost American families $1,700 a year.

No, Copenhagen is not dead. Quite the reverse — prospects for a global deal have never been better.

Posted: 27 Sep 2009 05:45 AM PDT

The usually savvy Mother Jones reporter, David Corn, has published a flawed analysis, "Is Copenhagen dead" (original here, repost here).

The media has a herd mentality when it comes to reporting on all things presidential — either you're up or you're down.  Indeed, the media likes to build up politicians and then tear them down.  So it is with Obama now.

Compounding that, the media likes a simple story, either great success or great failure.   Since the media (mis)perceives that both domestic and international climate action are on a down swing, even more piling on is inevitable.  Then again, some in the media believe temperatures are on the down swing, so what the frac do they know?

For eight years, Cheney-Bush not only muzzled climate scientists and blocked domestic action, they actively worked behind the sciences to kill any international deal.  It takes a lot of effort to unpoison a well.  And we've only had the possibility of serious international negotiations since January..  Anyone who thought there would be a final deal, signed and sealed in December, a mere 11 months later, wasn't paying attention to recent history and doesn't appreciate the nature of international negotiations.

The fact is, the news from China, India, Japan, and this country is far more positive toward the possibility of agreement than it has been for a decade or longer.  This is, finally, the one brief shining moment for action.

Does that mean there will be an ultimate deal that begins in Copenhagen?  Not at all.  The forces of denial and delay in this country in particular are strong and may still kill domestic action, which would in turn make a global deal very, very hard to achieve.

But I remain confident that Obama can and will deliver a domestic bill and an international agreement.   Since Corn based his misanalysis on a column coathored by the CEO of CAP, I'll let John Podesta have the final word with his reply, "Poised For Progress At The U.N. Climate Summit In Copenhagen":

While Mother Jones' David Corn is an excellent reporter, he is a lousy tealeaf reader. Mr. Corn misread a recent article by Dr. Rajendra Pachauri, the chair of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and Nobel Peace Prize winner, and myself in advance of the G20 summit, incorrectly concluding our purpose was to downplay expectations on behalf of the Administration. Mr. Corn's interpretation of our piece is inaccurate. Dr. Pachauri, one of the world's foremost advocates for strong global action on climate change, and I both recognize that significant challenges remain in advance of the U.N. summit in December. But we are confident that the international community is poised to make substantial progress on climate change in Copenhagen, and that the U.S. is now in a position to exercise renewed leadership in pursuit of a best-case climate scenario.The purpose of our September 23 piece was to emphasize the importance of climate change in advance of the G20 meetings and encourage the world's top emitters to seize an important opportunity to take concrete steps to move forward in advance of December's summit. It is not news that the divide between the unwieldy groups of developed and developing countries have stalled climate talks in the past and that they are drifting again. It is, however, noteworthy that major emitters have recently utilized new channels — the Administration's Major Economies Forum, for example, as well as the U.S.-China Strategic and Economic Dialogue — to lay the groundwork for a new climate agreement in Copenhagen. We think this is an important development and should be pursued whenever opportunities, like this week's summit, arise. Our piece urged leaders at the G20 to pursue concrete actions prior to Copenhagen on issues such as financing arrangements, technology cooperation, and deforestation prevention to increase the chances of success in December.

Even in the midst of global economic crisis, climate change has remained at the top of the agenda both in the United States and in key countries around the world. There is broad consensus that the effects of climate change are not only real, but will be devastating to developed and developing countries alike if the international community fails to agree on a global emissions reduction strategy soon. The road ahead is not without obstacles, which our piece pointed out. But the fate of Copenhagen is far from sealed — and it is my strong belief that the Obama Administration is committed to doing all it can to lead the world into a low-carbon, clean energy future.


Climate Week: Check the Highlight Reel GREENandSAVE


The Global Campaign for Climate Action opens in Montréal ... MaximsNews Network


Video: Greenland's fast-melting ice Aljazeera.net


Sunday, September 27, 2009

"Heroes of the Environment 2009"


Climate Progress

Climate Progress



Time magazine names me one of the "Heroes of the Environment 2009″

Posted: 27 Sep 2009 08:15 AM PDT

I have to admit — sometimes Joe Romm ruins my mornings. As the author of Climate Progress, one of the most influential global-warming blogs on the Internet, few debates on energy or the environment get past his ravenous attention, and he takes particular pleasure in targeting mainstream journalists who've written something he deems stupid. That's been me occasionally — like the time Romm took me to task for referencing an analysis on energy research and development he found wanting. At least I'm in good company: writers from the New York Times, the Washington Post and the Wall Street Journal have all been the subject of Romm posts.

Time CoverI don't know what's more suprising.  That Time named me one of its "Heroes of the Environment 2009" — I certainly don't see myself as a hero.  Or that they gave the assignment to Bryan Walsh, given my earlier critique of one of his pieces — and he still wrote such a generous profile, which continues:

But here's the thing — more often than not Romm's right. A physics Ph.D. from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), Romm, 49, clearly has brains to spare. He combines that intellect with a strong sense of moral outrage. He also possesses a Jon Stewart-like quality for pointing out the absurdity of his opponents.

Unlike many climate bloggers, Romm comes at global warming not from an environmental background but from a national-security one. After graduating from MIT, he worked at the Rockefeller Foundation. His job in the twilight of the Cold War was to identify the world's new big problems — and as he talked to experts across the ideological spectrum, he found them: energy and climate change. "These were the sleeper issues that were really going to dominate the coming decades," says Romm.

The 1990s were spent working for the Clinton Administration in Washington, where for several years he was an acting assistant secretary at the Department of Energy, an experience that put him well ahead of the curve on green power. But it wasn't until Romm's brother lost his house in Mississippi during Hurricane Katrina that climate change became personal. Romm began an in-depth research project to determine whether his brother should rebuild there. The result was the 2006 global-warming book Hell and High Water, which displayed a trademark urgency that bordered on hectoring. "The consequences of doing nothing were far more than what people realized," he says.

It's become Romm's mission to make people realize that — and his Climate Progress blog is the perfect vehicle for this son of a newspaper editor. What began as a once-a-day side job has become full time, with Romm scouring the Internet for climate studies and filtering them through his own firmly fixed values: that global warming is a potential human catastrophe, but that it can be fixed with today's green technology, applied relentlessly. It's "excellent and indispensable," as New York Times columnist — and new green champion — Thomas Friedman likes to say.

It's also much needed therapy for a writer who spends his time worrying about the fate of the world. "I used to be very frustrated," he says. "But the blog keeps my blood pressure down."

Indeed, it does (see "Why I blog").

Walsh is a good reporter, as evidenced by his 2008 cover story, "How to Win the War on Global Warming," which I thought was first rate.

[Note: If anyone has come here because of the Time story, be sure to read "An Introduction to Climate Progress."]

Time sent a great photographer, Jordan Hollender, who took a lot of photos.  I might try to post some of the others.  I'm a little surprised this is the one they used but I certainly do sometimes blog with my daughter on my lap.  And she certainly is a great motivation for me to fight to preserve a livable climate for the next generation.

One final comment on the subject of heroes.  When your father is a newspaper editor and your mother is also a journalist and your older brother collects comic books, it's hard not to see journalists as heroes.

Clark Kent, of course, was (is?) a mild-mannered reporter for a great metropolitan newspaper.  Peter Parker was a newspaper photographer.  Journalists were secret heroes.  With Woodward and Bernstein and All The President's Men, real journalists themselves became movie heroes to my generation.  But now, a great many journalists have become part of the establishment, like Woodward himself, defenders of the status quo, like David Broder, stenographer of those centrists who are fatally uninformed about global warming.

Certainly I have the greatest respect for Time magazine, which continues to do the best science-based global warming coverage of any major national magazine (see "Time: How climate change is causing a new age of extinction").  So this means a lot coming from them, though it is ironic that I am being recognized in part for taking on the media itself, for being in some sense an anti-journalist, like Jon Stewart.

Let me end with Time's framing of this issue:

From saving wild mountain rivers in China to measuring the Arctic's icy expanse, from protecting the lush forests of Africa to conducting a feisty online debate, our green heroes are informed by this simple notion: We can all make a difference….

It's easy to think that all the hard decisions are in the hands of our leaders alone. Not true. As the men and women in the following pages prove, we can all make a difference. Pen Hadow, leader of a daring survey across the Arctic to measure the thickness of sea ice, puts it this way: "Turning off a standby light once won't make a difference.. Do it for the rest of your life and that amounts to something. And if everybody's doing something, then we're moving in the right direction." We hope our environmental heroes provide both inspiration and action. Like financial pundits, most of them embrace the idea that a crisis also presents opportunity. They are heroes because they set out to discover what that opportunity might be.

We can all make a difference.  Indeed, we must.

World exclusive* video premier: Simulating and stimulating climate hope

Posted: 26 Sep 2009 11:57 AM PDT

If you want a stirring stemwinder on climate action, here it is.

The speaker is my good friend Drew Jones, coauthor of this guest blog post ("Only the most ambitious emissions reductions under discussion within UNFCCC can achieve climate goals").

As you'll see, Drew took to heart my earlier "Advice to a young climate blogger [and public speaker]: Always use WWII metaphors.

*Technically, this can't be the world premiere since the video is online.  But Drew has withheld posting it anywhere else so this is the official non-YouTube world premiere.

I'm not quite as optimistic as Drew is in this talk, but more good news keeps coming from key countries like China, India, and Japan.  I am going to launch a multipart series on this important topic this week.

For more of Drew's work, click here.


James Hansen, In His Own Words Treehugger


Op-Ed Columnist The New Sputnik New York Times - New York,NY,USA

Op-Ed Columnist The New Sputnik
New York Times - New York,NY,USA

The New Sputnik New York Times - New York,NY,USA

The New Sputnik
New York Times - New York,NY,USA

Solar Power, Without All Those Panels New York Times


Climate Progress

Climate Progress



Honey, I shrunk the GOP, Part 3: RNC Chair Steele withdraws support for Rep. Kirk over his vote on climate and clean energy bill

Posted: 26 Sep 2009 06:54 AM PDT

shrunkthegopPart 1 looked at how, conservatives vowed to purge all members who support clean energy or science-based policy following the House vote on the climate bill.

That anti-climate litmus test threatens the health and well-being of our children and grandchildren — and will ultimately prove self-destructive for conservatives, too, as noted in Part 2: Opposing clean energy hurts GOP — Mellman.  More recent polling further underscores the danger of opposing the clean air, clean water, clean energy jobs bill (see Swing state poll finds 60% "would be more likely to vote for their senator if he or she supported the bill" and Independents support the bill 2-to-1).

Now Think Progress reports on another striking GOP effort to purge a member who failed the litmus test:

This past June, Rep. Mark Kirk (R-IL) — who is now running for Senate — was one of the eight Republicans to cast a vote in favor of Waxman-Markey clean energy legislation. But ever since Kirk began taking heat from the likes of Rush Limbaugh and Glenn Beck, he has been trying desperately to backtrack from his vote.

Kirk has since offered contradictory explanations for his shifting stance. "I voted for [cap-and-trade] because it was in the narrow interests of my congressional district," he explained recently. But at the time of his vote, Kirk cited "national security" considerations, "arguing that a modest carbon tax would spur development of domestic energy sources and reduce dependence on oil controlled by Saudi sheiks and Venezuelan dictators."

steele

Now, RNC Chairman Michael Steele is feeling the heat from the right-wing base as well, and is pulling a flip-flop of his own. The Chicago Daily Observer reports that Steele is withdrawing his support from Kirk:

"Republican National Chairman Michael Steele has withdrawn his sole endorsement for Mark Kirk for the U. S. Senate, recognizing that the candidacy of Patrick Hughes has drawn major support from Illinois Republicans: thus Steele's RNC is neutral … a distinct victory for Hughes."

Steele has previously referred to Kirk as a rising star and someone he would support. "I'm so excited about Mark Kirk and his race," Steele said in a radio interview. "We were all kind of sitting around with bated breath as he was making his decision, a very personal decision, a family decision, to run for the Senate."

"You have absolutely no reason, none, to trust our word or our actions at this point," Steele told Glenn Beck in February. This of course remains an ongoing challenge for conservatives.

Anti-science conservatives have tied their future to policies that would inevitably lead to catastrophic climate change and impoverishment of this country — and that would  cede leadership in the clean energy technologies that will be the biggest job-creating engine this century.  As the painful reality human-caused global warming becomes increasingly obvious, that is a political strategy that will keep shrinking the party.  Let's just hope that they disappear from sight in time for progressives to enact the policies needed to preserve a livable climate.

We aren't living in a Disney science fiction movie.  Even if the GOP is mired in science fictions, a happy ending is not guaranteed.

Photoshop credit to CAP's Lauren Ferguson.

Related Posts:

A Sea Change: Imagine a World without Fish — ocean acidification film — premiers tonight on Planet Green

Posted: 26 Sep 2009 05:43 AM PDT

Global warming is "capable of wrecking the marine ecosystem and depriving future generations of the harvest of the seas" (see Ocean dead zones to expand, "remain for thousands of years").

A new documentary on ocean acidification is airing tonight (Saturday) on Planet Green at 8 pm.  (You can find your Planet Green channel on their website.)  Here's the trailer:

For more on the subject with links to primary sources and recent studies, see "Imagine a World without Fish: Deadly ocean acidification — hard to deny, harder to geo-engineer, but not hard to stop — is subject of documentary."


Get Ready: Senate Climate Bill To Drop This Week Treehugger